Seminar Information
Links to Readings
- Skepticism and Interpretation
Argues that Davidson's arguments against the possibility of massive error are unsuccessful, ultimately because it requires an overly strong reading of the requirement that meanings be publicly available. - Semantics for Opaque Contexts
Criticizes Davidson's account of attitude contexts and offers a replacement which treats the relata of attitude reports as sentences rather than utterances. - Complex Demonstratives
Paper with Lepore on the semantic form of complex demonstratives. The central proposal is that 'That F' has the form '[The x: x is F and x is that]'. - Vagueness and the Sorities Paradox
On vagueness rather than Davidson, but background for the problem that vagueness presents for truth-theoretic semantics. - Davidson
An overview of Davidson's life and philosophy. - Ontology in the Theory of Meaning
A Davidson inspired argument against the utility of meanings in the theory of meaning. - Radical Misinterpretation: Reply to Stoutland
Correcting misunderstandings of Davidson and the book in a review by Fred Stoutland. - De Re Necessities
Deflationary semantics for modal statements with special attention to de re modal statements in a truth-theoretic framework. We won't be discussing this in the seminar. - Triangulation Triangulated
Takes a critical look at the appeal to triangulation in Davidson's later work to solve the problem of finding an objective ground for the object of thought. - The Problem with Radical Interpretation: replies to Evnine and Rawling
See pp. 139 ff. Replies to some commentary on the book focusing on the problem with radical interpretation. - Truth and Meaning Redux: Reply to Soames
A response to Soames's 2008 "Truth and Meaning: In Perspective" in which he argues Davidson's program has run its course. - Sententialism and Higher-order Attitude Attributions
A response to the higher-order attitude objection to sententialism that charges that the propositionalist has the same problem and the same moves are open to both approaches. - Review of volumes 3-5 of Davidson's collected papers
Review in Mind of Subjective, Intersubjective, Objective, Problems of Rationality, and Truth, Language and History. - Singular Thought and the Cartesian Theory of Mind
Defends, inter alia, the view that 'I am hungry' as used by me expresses the same proposition as 'Ludwig is hungry' despite our resistance to substituting in certain attitude contexts.
« In what way is a truth theory that meets Convention A superior to one that meets only Convention T? | Main
02/16/2010
The Group Photograph
The comments to this entry are closed.
Home Page:
TMD Handouts
- Handout #1
The Role of a Truth Theory in a Meaning Theory - Handout #2
Objections and Challenges to Truth-theoretic Semantics Met - Handout #3
What is Radical Interpretation? - Handout #4
The Impossibility of Radical Interpretation - Handout #5
Metaphysics and Epistemology: radically different conceptual schemes, impossibility of massive error, first person authority, inscrutability of reference. - Handout #6
Are There Any A Priori Arguments for Radical Interpretation?
Recent Comments
- Kirk Ludwig on In what way is a truth theory that meets Convention A superior to one that meets only Convention T?
- Irmela Wagner on In what way is a truth theory that meets Convention A superior to one that meets only Convention T?
- Kirk Ludwig on Does Knowledge of a Compositional Language "beg the question"?
- Miguel on Does Knowledge of a Compositional Language "beg the question"?
- Irmela Wagner on Does Knowledge of a Compositional Language "beg the question"?
- Irmela Wagner on Does Knowledge of a Compositional Language "beg the question"?
- Irmela Wagner on Does Knowledge of a Compositional Language "beg the question"?
Recent Posts
- The Group Photograph
- In what way is a truth theory that meets Convention A superior to one that meets only Convention T?
- Loose Ends Will Be Cleared Up
- The content of a meaning theory and knowledge of a language
- Inscrutability
- Truth-theoretic Semantics and Speaker Competence
- Does Knowledge of a Compositional Language "beg the question"?
- Convention A and Davidson's Position
- I am about to be eaten by a great white shark
- Semantical Primitives
Comments